As an experienced water heater specialist, I’m often asked about the efficiency differences between tankless and storage tank water heaters. Both have their own advantages, and the “best” option can vary depending on a homeowner’s specific needs and preferences. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive deep into the energy efficiency comparisons, maintenance requirements, installation considerations, and overall cost factors to help you determine the most suitable water heater for your home.
Now, this might seem counterintuitive when dealing with water heaters…
Water Heater Types
Tankless Water Heaters
Tankless water heaters, also known as on-demand or instantaneous water heaters, operate quite differently from traditional storage tank models. Instead of storing a large volume of heated water, tankless units only heat water when it’s needed. This “on-demand” heating process is triggered when a hot water tap is turned on, passing cold water through a heat exchanger that rapidly warms the water to the desired temperature.
The key benefit of tankless water heaters is their energy efficiency. Without the need to continuously maintain a full tank of hot water, they avoid the standby heat losses associated with storage tank units. The U.S. Department of Energy estimates that tankless water heaters can be 24-34% more energy-efficient for homes using 41 gallons or less of hot water daily, and up to 14% more efficient for households with higher hot water demands around 86 gallons per day.
However, tankless water heaters do have some limitations. Their flow rate is generally lower than storage tank models, which can be an issue for simultaneous, high-demand uses like running a shower and dishwasher at the same time. To overcome this, some homeowners opt to install multiple tankless units or pair them with a small buffer tank.
Storage Tank Water Heaters
Traditional storage tank water heaters maintain a reservoir of pre-heated water, ready for use whenever a hot water tap is opened. These models continuously keep the water at a set temperature, typically between 120°F and 140°F, to double-check that a reliable supply of hot water is available on-demand.
While storage tank water heaters have higher standby heat losses compared to tankless units, they can often provide a higher flow rate to handle concurrent hot water needs. They are also generally less expensive upfront, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious homeowners.
According to Consumer Reports, gas-powered storage tank water heaters are 22% more efficient than their tankless counterparts. This efficiency gap is largely due to the standby heat losses of storage tanks, which can be minimized through proper insulation and placement.
Hybrid Water Heaters
In recent years, a third type of water heater has gained popularity – the hybrid or heat pump water heater. These units combine the storage tank design with a highly efficient heat pump technology to extract heat from the surrounding air and transfer it to the water.
Hybrid water heaters can be up to 3 times more energy-efficient than standard electric storage tank models, with the potential to save homeowners hundreds of dollars annually on their utility bills. However, they tend to have higher upfront costs and may not be suitable for all climates, as the heat pump function is less effective in colder environments.
Water Heater Efficiency
Energy Efficiency Ratings
When evaluating the energy efficiency of water heaters, it’s important to consider their Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) or Energy Factor (EF) ratings. These metrics provide a standardized way to compare the overall efficiency of different models, taking into account factors like fuel type, standby losses, and recovery efficiency.
UEF and EF ratings range from 0 to 1, with higher numbers indicating more energy-efficient water heaters. Tankless water heaters typically have UEF ratings between 0.81 and 0.96, while storage tank models range from 0.58 to 0.70. Hybrid heat pump water heaters can achieve even higher UEF ratings, often exceeding 2.0.
Fuel Sources and Consumption
The type of fuel or energy source used by a water heater can also have a significant impact on its efficiency and operating costs. The three most common fuel sources are electricity, natural gas, and propane.
Generally, gas-powered water heaters tend to be more energy-efficient than electric models, as they convert a higher percentage of their fuel into usable heat. However, the relative costs of electricity and natural gas/propane in your local area will ultimately determine which fuel source is the most cost-effective option.
It’s also worth noting that tankless water heaters with a continuously burning pilot light can potentially negate some of their energy efficiency advantages, as the pilot light itself consumes a small amount of gas even when hot water is not in use. Opting for a tankless model with an intermittent ignition device (IID) can help mitigate this issue.
Insulation and Heat Loss
Proper insulation is crucial for maximizing the energy efficiency of any water heater, whether it’s a tankless or storage tank unit. Standby heat losses can account for a significant portion of a water heater’s overall energy consumption, especially in storage tank models that constantly maintain a reservoir of hot water.
Tankless water heaters generally have lower standby heat losses since they only heat water on-demand. However, the location of the unit and the quality of insulation around the heat exchanger can still impact their efficiency. For storage tank water heaters, ensuring the tank is well-insulated and situated in a warm environment (e.g., not in a cold garage or basement) can help minimize standby heat losses.
Water Heater Maintenance
Proper maintenance is essential for optimizing the energy efficiency and longevity of any water heater, regardless of the type. Here are some key maintenance tasks to keep in mind:
Anode Rod Replacement
The anode rod is a sacrificial metal component inside the water heater tank that helps prevent corrosion. Over time, the anode rod will gradually deteriorate and need to be replaced, typically every 3-5 years. Neglecting this maintenance can lead to premature tank failure and decreased efficiency.
Sediment Flushing
Both tankless and storage tank water heaters can accumulate mineral sediment and scale buildup, which can impede heat transfer and reduce efficiency. Flushing the system periodically (annually for tankless, every 6 months for storage tanks) helps remove these deposits and maintain optimal performance.
Thermostat Adjustment
Ensuring the water heater’s thermostat is set to the recommended temperature, typically between 120°F and 140°F, can help prevent energy waste and scalding risks. Adjusting the thermostat to the appropriate setting for your household’s needs is a simple yet effective way to improve efficiency.
Plumbing Techniques
The selection of plumbing materials and installation methods can also impact the overall efficiency and longevity of a water heater system. Here are some key considerations:
Pipe Material Selection
Choosing the right pipe materials for your hot water distribution system is important. Copper and cross-linked polyethylene (PEX) are two of the most common and efficient options, as they minimize heat loss through the pipes. Older materials like galvanized steel or polybutylene can be less efficient and prone to corrosion over time.
Connections and Fittings
Proper connections and fittings are crucial for preventing leaks and maximizing the efficiency of the water heater system. Using high-quality brass or stainless steel fittings, along with techniques like soldering for copper pipes, can help double-check that a secure, leak-free installation.
Expansion Tank Installation
For storage tank water heaters, installing an expansion tank is recommended to accommodate the increased volume of water as it heats up. This helps prevent excessive pressure buildup and potential leaks, which can otherwise reduce the system’s efficiency and lifespan.
Installation Methods
The way a water heater is installed can also have a significant impact on its performance and energy efficiency. Here are some key considerations:
Tankless Water Heater Placement
Proper placement and venting are critical for tankless water heaters. These units should be installed close to the primary hot water outlets to minimize heat loss through the pipes. Ensuring adequate airflow and proper venting (either direct or power-vented) is also essential for safe and efficient operation.
Storage Tank Sizing Considerations
When selecting a storage tank water heater, it’s important to choose the right size to match your household’s hot water demands. Oversizing the tank can lead to increased standby heat losses and energy waste, while undersizing can result in insufficient hot water availability. Consulting with a professional can help determine the optimal tank size for your home.
Venting and Exhaust Requirements
Proper venting is crucial for both tankless and storage tank water heaters, especially those that use natural gas or propane as the fuel source. Ensuring the water heater is connected to the appropriate venting system, whether it’s a traditional flue or a power-vented exhaust, helps double-check that safe and efficient operation.
Cost Considerations
When comparing tankless and storage tank water heaters, the overall cost is an important factor to consider. This includes both the upfront installation expenses and the long-term energy savings.
Upfront Installation Costs
Tankless water heaters generally have a higher initial cost compared to storage tank models. According to Major Energy, the installation of a gas-powered tankless unit can range from $1,000 to $2,000, while an electric tankless heater typically costs $1,000 to $1,500. In contrast, a traditional storage tank water heater may cost between $400 and $900 for the unit and installation.
Long-Term Energy Savings
While tankless water heaters have higher upfront costs, they can potentially offer significant long-term energy savings. The U.S. Department of Energy estimates that a gas-powered tankless water heater can save around $100 per year on energy costs compared to a storage tank model, while an electric tankless unit can save approximately $44 annually.
These savings can help offset the higher initial investment over the lifespan of the water heater, which is typically 20-30 years for a tankless unit and 10-15 years for a storage tank model.
Rebates and Incentives
To further enhance the cost-effectiveness of energy-efficient water heaters, many local and federal governments offer rebates, tax credits, and other incentives. Checking with your utility provider or local government agencies can help you identify any available programs that may apply to your water heater purchase and installation.
Environmental Impact
Beyond energy efficiency and cost savings, the environmental impact of water heaters is also an important consideration for many homeowners. Here are a few key factors to keep in mind:
Greenhouse Gas Emissions
The fuel source used by a water heater directly impacts its greenhouse gas emissions. Generally, electric water heaters have a lower carbon footprint than gas-powered models, as the electricity grid continues to incorporate more renewable energy sources. However, the specific emissions of your local electricity grid should be taken into account.
Water Conservation
Tankless water heaters can contribute to water conservation by only heating water on-demand, rather than continuously maintaining a full tank. This can be particularly beneficial in areas with limited water resources or high water costs.
Renewable Energy Integration
For homeowners interested in renewable energy, tankless water heaters can be more easily integrated with solar photovoltaic systems or other distributed generation sources. This can further enhance the environmental benefits and long-term cost savings of the water heater system.
In conclusion, when it comes to choosing between tankless and storage tank water heaters, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. The “best” option will depend on your specific household needs, budget, and environmental priorities. By carefully evaluating the energy efficiency, maintenance requirements, installation factors, and cost considerations, you can make an informed decision that will provide reliable, cost-effective, and eco-friendly hot water for your home.
If you’re in the market for a new water heater, be sure to visit WaterHeaterPick.com for even more in-depth guides, reviews, and expert advice to help you find the perfect fit.
Example: Addressing Leaks in Water Heaters 2023
